How to Choose a Shopify Agency: 12 Questions to Ask First
Quick answer: to choose a Shopify agency, check three things: real work you can see, real client proof, and a clear fixed price. Then ask how they will measure success and who you will talk to every week. The 12 questions below help you compare agencies fairly.
Key takeaways
- Look at stores and ad accounts the agency actually runs.
- Ask for client reviews, recorded calls or references.
- Get a written scope and fixed price before you pay.
- Agree on the numbers that define success.
12 questions to ask before you hire a Shopify agency
- Can I see 3 Shopify stores you built? Live links, not only screenshots.
- Can you show real ad results? Screenshots or recordings from Ads Manager.
- Do you have client reviews? On Clutch, Google, Shopify Partners or video calls.
- Who will do the work? The founder, a team member or a subcontractor?
- How do we talk each week? WhatsApp, email, calls, reports?
- What exactly is included? Pages, products, copy, apps, tracking, revisions.
- What costs extra? Apps, themes, ad spend, extra revisions.
- How will you measure success? Conversion rate, cost per purchase, ROAS, sales.
- Will you check my tracking? Meta pixel, Conversions API and Google Analytics.
- Who owns the work? Store design, creatives and ad accounts should be yours.
- What happens after launch? Support if something breaks.
- Can we start small? An audit or a small first project before a big commitment.
Red flags to watch for
- Guaranteed results or guaranteed ROAS.
- No live examples of their work.
- They want to run ads from their own ad account instead of yours.
- Vague pricing that changes after you start.
- Nobody can explain the plan in simple words.
Scorecard to compare agencies
| Check | Agency A | Agency B | Agency C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Real store examples | |||
| Real ad results | |||
| Client reviews | |||
| Fixed written price | |||
| Clear weekly communication | |||
| You own accounts and files |
See how agencies compare by size and budget in Best Shopify Agencies in 2026, and whether you need an agency at all in Shopify Agency vs Freelancer vs In-House.
How we handle this at CreativeWebBoost: you can see our live work on the work page, watch real client calls on the reviews page, and get a fixed written price before you pay anything.
This article is part of Shopify & E-commerce Growth Guides. Want it done for you? See our pricing.
Frequently asked questions
What should a Shopify agency include in a proposal?
A clear scope, timeline, fixed price, what is included and excluded, how you communicate, and how success is measured.
Should a Shopify agency guarantee sales?
No honest agency can guarantee sales or ROAS. They can promise a clear process, good work and honest reporting.
Is a Shopify Partner agency better?
Shopify Partner status shows they work on the platform, but always check real work and reviews too.
How much should I budget for a Shopify agency?
Small projects start from a few hundred dollars; large custom builds can cost tens of thousands. See our pricing and Shopify store design cost guide.
Talk to us first, free
Book a free call or get a free store audit. See our services.
Md Forhad has worked in e-commerce for 5+ years, designing Shopify stores, running Facebook and Instagram ads and making AI video ads for brands in jewelry, grooming, dancewear and barber supplies. He has shared real client calls and store reviews on YouTube since 2020.
Want us to do this for your store?
Get a free store audit or book a free 30-minute call. We design Shopify stores, run Facebook & Instagram ads and make AI video ads.
Book a free callFree store audit